Bose files

On 15/10/2015 Prime Minister Narendra Modi met members of the Bose family and said the process to declassify Bose files will begin after 100 days on 23/10/2016 on the birth anniversary of Subhash Chandra Bose. That reminds me of his promise to bring back black money from foreign countries and put 15 lakh rupees in every Indian’s account within 100 days of coming to power.
Making public Bose files was one of the promises Modi made during his election speeches and it should have been fulfilled more than a year ago. Modi did not fulfil many of the promises he made. The promise of One Rank One Pension was partially fulfilled after ex-servicemen began fast unto death and there was huge negative publicity. In September West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee made public Bose files with her government and that forced Modi’s hand. He agreed to meet Members of Modi family but delayed it by one month and process of publication is delayed by further 100 days.
Congress while in power refused to make public Bose files claiming it will adversely affect relations.
It is said there was surveillance on Bose family till 1968. It is known West Bengal State Intelligence Bureau opened letters addressed to Bose family members and some letters did not reach Bose family members.
Some claim Bose did not die on 18/8/1945. Some claim he was a prisoner in USSR for 12 years and died there. Some claim he went to China. WB files did not put an end to that speculation.
M. O. Mathai was Principal Private Secretary to Jawaharlal Nehru. Mission Netaji was an organisation involved in finding out about Subhash Chandra Bose’s death. Mission Netaji got hold M. O. Mathai’s letter UO No. DS/13170 dt. 2/12/1954 which indicated Bose’s ashes were received in India between 1950 and 1954. India’s official position is Bose’s ashes are in Renkoji Temple in Tokyo Japan. It is possible that some ashes were received in India and some are in Renkoji Temple. Jawaharlal Nehru, Rajendra Prasad, Indira Gandhi and Atal Behari Vajpayee had visited the temple.
Shah Nawaz Committee, Khosla Commission and Mukherjee Commission inquired into the death of Bose. Shah Nawaz Committee and Khosla Commission concluded Bose died in plane crash. Mukherjee Commission concluded Bose did not die in plane crash. The Government of India rejected the findings of Mukherjee Commission.
The publication of Bose files with the Government of India will hopefully put an end to speculation about Bose’s death.

Right to eat meat

Right to eat meat is a natural right. It is implicit in the Fundamental Rights of life and liberty, religion, profession and equality. It is not right to demand and enforce ban on meat.
There is no compulsion to eat meat. There are vegetarians of different types who want to impose their views on others. Sometimes it is for religious reasons which amounts to imposing one’s religious practice on others.
India is a multi-religious country. When people of one religion demand that they should be respected and others should abstain from meat it leads to anger, resentment and hostility.
Beef, chicken, mutton and pork are eaten in many parts of the world. In India in some states beef is banned. After beef ban in Maharashtra prices of chicken, mutton and pork went up.
Sometimes people have gone to court against meat bans. When judges were vegetarians they did not succeed.
There are people who generally eat meat during the year but abstain during a season or on particular days. Different religions have different days of abstinence.
Some abstain from meat, fish and eggs. Jains abstain from meat, fish, eggs, onions, garlic, potatoes, ginger, carrot, other root vegetables and honey. Jains wanting to have meat ban for eight days during Paryushan this year led to hostile reaction. BJP was in favour of ban. Shiv Sena, MNS, Congress, NCP and MIM opposed ban. For once, Shiv Sena and MIM were on the same side. One member of Shiv Sena said it is violence in the name of non-violence. Another member of Shiv Sena said it is religious terrorism. Shiv Sena’s newspaper editorial warned Jains their wealth can turn to ash within minutes. BJP was accused of minority appeasement.
For Buddhists killing of animals is forbidden, eating meat is not forbidden.
For Jews and Muslims pork is forbidden.
For Christians laws differ according to the Church. Canon Law for Latin Rite forbids eating meat on Fridays but empowers Bishops’ Conferences to prescribe other measures. In place of abstinence other forms of penance or works of charity can be substituted. Ash Wednesday and Good Friday are days of abstinence. Many Christians abstain from meat on Fridays and during Lent.
Vegans abstain from meat, fish, eggs, milk, butter, cheese, cream, yoghurt, ghee, and whey.
A day of fast for one can be a day of feast for another. It is not possible to please everyone and no effort should be made to please anyone and ban meat. Life will be impossible if everything someone or the other does not like is banned.
There should be no ban on sale or eating of meat on any day. Abattoirs should not be closed to please someone’s religious sentiments. Ban on beef should be lifted. For some meat ban means loss of work and income.

One Rank One Pension

On 5/9/2015 Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar announced government’s version of One Rank One Pension (OROP) which failed to satisfy many ex-servicemen. The issue started in 1973 and the last word is not said.
In 2014 during Lok Sabha elections BJP had promised OROP within 100 days of coming to power. Ex-servicemen had faith in Narendra Modi and they voted for him. It took 15 months and 10 days to partially fulfil the promise.
Congress held a press conference. A. K. Antony, Kapil Sibal, and Randeep Singh Surjewala addressed journalists. Congress claimed credit for OROP because they had accepted it in principle in February 2014 and allotted 500 crore rupees in interim budget. It blamed BJP for dilution of OROP. Minster of State for External Affairs and former General Vijay Kumar Singh said those who did nothing for 42 years have no right to talk. Poor fellow was unaware that out of these 42 years Atal Behari Vajpayee was Prime Minister for six years (1998-2004), Janata Party was in power in 1977-79 and BJP had supported Vishwanath Pratap Singh government in 1989-90. Congress had supported Charan Singh in 1979, Chandra Shekhar government in 1990-91 and Deve Gowda and I. K. Gujral governments in 1996-97.
Vijay Kumar Singh can be excused for his ignorance. Not Narendra Modi. He said something similar on 6/9/2015.
What BJP has agreed to implement is One Rank Many Pensions. The average of maximum and minimum pension will be given to those who get less than average pension. Those who get more than average pension will retain their pension.
BJP had promised OROP with effect from 1/4/2014 in Parliament. Now it is with effect from 1/7/2014. The excuse is BJP came to power on 26/5/2014. But BJP had made that promise after they came to power. Veterans were not happy with it but they accepted it.
Revision of pension is every five years. Veterans wanted revision every year or at least every two years.
Government has announced one-member judicial commission on OROP for a period of six months. Veterans want five-member commission with three veterans as members for a period of one month. Government says calculations take a long time. Veterans say there is a computer programme that can calculate in 15 minutes.
Government said those who took VRS will not get OROP. Veterans said there is no VRS in armed forces, they have premature retirement. Government accepted that contention.
Congress claiming credit for OROP is laughable. For long they opposed OROP. In 2009 they had said there were administrative, technical and financial difficulties in implementing OROP. When elections drew near in 2014 they agreed for OROP to get votes of veterans. It was too late and was of no use.
Political reactions have been predictable. Those who are on BJP side have said it is a great achievement. Those who are on the opposite side have found faults with it.
Veterans have given up fast unto death and are continuing their agitation at Jantar Mantar with chain hunger strike.
One argument against OROP has been it will cost huge money and government cannot afford it. This argument is not valid. Central government is never short of money. Whenever it wants money it prints notes. Narendra Modi announced Bihar package of more than 2 lakh crore rupees. Public sector banks have lost lakhs of crores of rupees due to corporate debt restructuring. In the name of recapitalisation, government has printed notes and given to banks. Property of defaulters is not confiscated. Money is lost in NREGA and various schemes. Nothing is done to stop them.
Veterans waited for OROP. In March 2014 Defence Ministry finished its calculations and sent to Finance Ministry. According to veterans it was close to 8,300 crore rupees. Things got stuck up at Finance Ministry. Veterans waited for a year. They expected Narendra Modi to announce OROP at Mathura on 25/5/2015. That did not happen. Veterans lost patience. They began their agitation at Jantar Mantar. There was no effect. On 14/8/2015 NDMC officials and policepersons tried to remove veterans forcibly which created outrage. Modi did not announce OROP during his Independence Day speech at Red Fort on 15/8/2015. On 16/8/2015 two veterans began fast unto death and later some more veterans joined them. Veterans did not get appointment to meet Prime Minister. Veterans were angry. They threatened to intensify their agitation and spread it across the country and campaign against BJP in Bihar elections. Commemoration of 1965 War became a casualty.
Satbir Singh was on many TV channels giving the view of veterans. V. K. Gandhi and Amit Kaul were sometimes on TV.
MPs get pension irrespective of the time one was an MP. They get their salaries and allowances even when they disrupt Parliament and no work takes place. They have the power to increase their salaries, allowances, perks and privileges as they like. The bills get passed quickly without disruption and with unanimity. There is Parliament canteen subsidy. Bureaucrats get OROP.
BJP broke many promises. Prominent among them is to make public names of black money holders in foreign accounts and bring back black money from foreign countries and put 15 lakh rupees in account of every Indian within 100 days. Promises to make Henderson-Brookes Report and Subhash Chandra Bose files public were broken. If veterans had not started their agitation and resorted to fast unto death the promise of OROP which is fulfilled partially would have been broken.