Voice from the rooftop logo
Menu
  • World
  • India
  • USA
  • Sports/Games/Cricket
  • Media
  • Education
  • Christianity
  • Corruption
  • Terrorism
Menu

Women and reservations in legislatures

Posted on March 6, 2010 by Vincent Augustine D'Souza

On 8/3/2010 bill for one third reservation for women in legislatures is to be presented in the Rajya Sabha. I am opposed to the bill.
Those who favour the bill give various arguments justifying it. One strange argument is that only 10% of women win elections. Only 10% or less women win elections was not mentioned.
The bill is elitist, unjust and undemocratic. The argument that women are 50% of the population and hold 10% of seats does not hold water. Women are free to contest 100% of seats. If women vote for women candidates women representatives will be more. Many women don’t vote for women candidates. They, like men, vote for parties. With 33% reservation women will be free to contest 100% seats while men can only contest 67% seats.
Reservation for women in rural and urban bodies should not have been there and should go.
Reservation will mean women from families of existing legislators will become candidates. It will not help ordinary women. To say that even if they are family members they are women is not a sound argument.
Women who are competent win elections. Indira Gandhi became prime minister. Pratibha Patil became president. There have been many women chief ministers. Some of them are leaders of their parties. All of them succeeded without reservations. Reservation for women in legislatures will mean incompetent women will become legislators.

1 thought on “Women and reservations in legislatures”

  1. Nelson says:
    March 7, 2010 at 1:01 am

    There shouldn’t be any reservations.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Alpabharata by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
Alpabharata by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
Dream Novel Vincent Augustibe D'Souza
Pope Novel Vincent Augustibe D'Souza
King Novel Vincent Augustibe D'Souza

Recent Posts

  • Yashwant versus Draupadi
  • Mamata Upstages Sonia
  • Nupur and Naveen
  • Vijay Singla Arrest
  • India Win Thomas Cup

Recent Comments

  • Matheikal on Mamata Upstages Sonia
  • Matheikal on Nupur and Naveen
  • Matheikal on BJP to TMC
  • Matheikal on India Most Populous
  • Priyarani Gouda on India Against Sanctions

Categories

  • America (50)
  • Christianity (33)
  • Corruption (45)
  • Cricket (59)
  • Education (14)
  • General (75)
  • India (763)
  • Media (32)
  • Pakistan (20)
  • Sports and Games (30)
  • Terrorism (30)
  • World (68)

RSS Go 4 Quiz

  • Amsterdam Olympics 1928 Quiz
  • Pedro II Quiz
  • Belarus Quiz
  • Bangalore Test October 2008 Quiz (India Vs Australia Test Cricket)
  • William Bradford Shockley Quiz
  • Edvard Munch Quiz
  • Garry Marshall Quiz
  • Wimbledon 2013 Quiz
  • Tonga Quiz
  • Melbourne Olympics 1956 Quiz
Model Constitution for India by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
Model Constitution for India by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
English-Konkani Dictionary by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
English-Konkani Dictionary by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
Model Constitution for the United States of America by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
Model Constitution for the United States of America by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
©2022 Voice from the rooftop | Made By Superb Themes