Voice from the rooftop logo
Menu
  • World
  • India
  • USA
  • Sports/Games/Cricket
  • Media
  • Education
  • Christianity
  • Corruption
  • Terrorism
Menu

Judges as information commissioners

Posted on September 16, 2012 by Vincent Augustine D'Souza

The Supreme Court judgment on the composition of information commissions is a new milestone in judicial overreach. The judges have said information commissions are judicial tribunals, only retired or serving justices of Supreme Court or chief justices of High Courts can head information commissions. The benches of information commissions should have two members, one of them a judicial member. Lawyers with 20 years experience are also eligible as judicial members. The bench comprising Justices A. K. Patnaik and Swatanter Kumar directed the central government to amend the RTI Act. Some busybody had challenged the qualifications in RTI Act. The judges qualified themselves.

It is not for judiciary to direct legislature to pass or amend a law. Judiciary is not above executive and legislature. This judgment gives employment to judges after retirement. If serving judges are appointed court cases will be delayed. Some days back CJI Sarosh H. Kapadia had warned against judicial overreach. This judgment ignores that warning.

Retired judges are appointed as chairpersons of human rights commissions, Press Council, inquiry commissions and so on. This is another opportunity for them.

Lokesh Batra, an RTI activist, said “It appears that the Supreme Court has created over 50% reservations for retired judges in information commissions. I hope we are not heading for hearing after hearing and reserved verdicts like in the courts, thus prolonging decisions for years.”

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trump Novel Vincent Augustibe D'Souza
Dream Novel Vincent Augustibe D'Souza
Pope Novel Vincent Augustibe D'Souza
King Novel Vincent Augustibe D'Souza

Recent Posts

  • Disha Gets Bail
  • Budget 2021
  • Republic Day 2021
  • Brisbane Test 2021
  • Nidhi Razdan Duped

Recent Comments

  • mark on Death of Phillip Hughes
  • Matheikal on Budget 2021
  • Matheikal on Republic Day 2021
  • Tomichan Matheikal on Washington Violence
  • Rajeev Moothedath on India 36 all out

Categories

  • America (50)
  • Christianity (33)
  • Corruption (44)
  • Cricket (59)
  • Education (14)
  • General (75)
  • India (721)
  • Media (32)
  • Pakistan (20)
  • Sports and Games (30)
  • Terrorism (30)
  • World (68)

RSS Go 4 Quiz

  • Margaret Mitchell Quiz
  • Bertrand Russell Quiz
  • Carl Sandburg Quiz
  • Katherine Hepburn Quiz
  • Austen Chamberlain Quiz
  • Robert Frost Quiz
  • Slumdog Millionaire Quiz II
  • Edward Victor Appleton Quiz
  • French Open 2015 Quiz
  • Australian Open 2015 Quiz
Model Constitution for India by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
Model Constitution for India by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
English-Konkani Dictionary by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
English-Konkani Dictionary by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
Model Constitution for the United States of America by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
Model Constitution for the United States of America by Vincent Augustine D'Souza
©2021 Voice from the rooftop | Made By Superb Themes