Tag: third test

Loss at Edgbaston

India lost the Test, the series and No. 1 ranking at Edgbaston. England beat India by an Innings and 242 runs. India were 224 in the first Innings and 244 in the second Innings. This is the worst defeat since Lord’s 1974. England declared their Innings 710/7. India’s batting was average, bowling was not good enough and dropped catches made it worse. The Test was over within four days. Virender Sehwag returned to Tests to be out to first ball in both Innings, in first Innings after UDRS appeal. Hopes that he can turn things around were dashed. For India, Mahendra Singh Dhoni was the top scorer in both Innings, 77 and 74 not out. India’s No. 1 ranking lasted 20 months.

After many years India lost three Tests in a row. With every Test the margin of defeat increased. India lost the first Test at Lord’s by 196 runs, the second at Trent Bridge by 319 runs and the third at Edgbaston by an Innings and 242 runs. However in the second Test bowlers took 20 wickets. The series that was dubbed as the champions versus the challengers proved one-sided.

What went wrong? England were a better side, a young side, they had home advantage, their bowlers were outstanding, but that does not explain the margins of defeat. Some blame IPL. Some blame Test players, especially bowlers, not playing first class matches in India. Some blame lack of preparation for the series. That is not the reason for the loss in third Test. Some say there is too much cricket and cricketers are tired. That is not the reason as cricketers who want rest are given rest. Injury to Zaheer Khan is mentioned as a reason but our bowling should not have been dependent on one bowler. There were other bowlers and sometimes they did well. Our fielding was bad and dropped catches cost matches. In the third Test India were a dejected and demoralised side as England piled up runs, there was no will to fight and players went through motions.

Some feel Gary Kirsten’s absence as coach has made the difference for India and Duncan Fletcher has failed. How much difference a coach makes is difficult to say. Under John Wright India were runners up in World Cup. Under Greg Chappell for sometime India were successful and then it was disaster. Under Gary Kirsten India achieved No. 1 ranking in Tests and won ODI World Cup. Duncan Fletcher was the coach for West Indies series and India won the ODIs 3-2 and Tests 1-0. Players who missed West Indies series did not do well in England.

BCCI is blamed for having its priorities wrong. BCCI is dominated by politicians and businessmen. Cricketers are unable to win elections. If defeats continue for India there will be no sponsors, Test, ODI and T20 matches will be less and Ranji Trophy matches will have importance.

Dethroned and disgraced, heroes to zeroes, were some of the expressions used to describe the loss. Some compared India’s bowling to county side. Some wondered how India became No. 1. India played well and that is why they became No. 1. They played bad and lost it.

There is one Test left. India can win that Test or draw it and avoid 0-4 defeat and salvage some pride.

India Loses Nagpur Test

India lost Nagpur Test by an Innings and 6 runs on 9/2/2010, fourth day of the Test. India’s Test ranking is No. 1 and South Africa’s No. 2.
As per original tour programme South Africa was to play seven ODIs. India defeated Sri Lanka in Tests at the end of 2009 and attained No. 1 ranking in Tests. India wanted a change in the series to retain its No. 1 status and the series was changed to two Tests and five ODIs.
India had a series in Bangladesh and won two Tests. Sreesanth, VVS Laxman, Rahul Dravid and Yuvraj Singh got injured.
India’s bowling and fielding was poor and batting was average. Dropped catches allowed South Africa to declare at 558/6. Ishant Sharma and Amit Misra did not get any wicket in spite of conceding 85 and 140 runs respectively.
South Africa was good in batting, bowling and its fielding could have been better. Dale Steyn’s bowling was outstanding. In India’s second Innings Sachin Tendulkar was dropped when he was 45 and he scored 100, his 46th Test century.
It was Mahendra Singh Dhoni’s 12th Test as captain and first loss. There are times for a captain when everything goes right and he keeps winning. Then comes a time when everything goes wrong and he keeps losing. I am reminded of Ajit Wadekar. He defeated West Indies in West Indies in 1971. West Indies’ fielding was poor. In England when India was to lose two Tests rain interrupted and the Tests ended in draw. India won the third Test at Oval. India won the 1972-1973 series against England in India. In 1974 India was in England lost all three Tests. In the second by an Innings and 265 runs. In the second Innings India was all out for 42. In the third Test England lost only two wickets. India lost the Test by an Innings and 78 runs. Mahendra Singh Dhoni had smooth sailing for most of the time. He won Twenty20 World Cup in 2007. After he became Test captain the Tests were won or draw. Now he has tasted defeat.
Selection committee has reacted by dropping three players, two of whom did not play the Test. This committee is supposed to be professional but nothing seems to have changed.
Link to e-book King – a novel: http://go4quiz.com/vincent/king